A very long time ago, on this very blog, I ranted about a Hilary Duff cover of The Who’s “My Generation”. A similar crime has been commited, and while admittedly it cannot possibly match the sheer heinousness of the Duff cover, it deserves to be similarly verbally ripped to pieces.
I was at Home Depot, where, oddly enough, strange things always seem to happen to me, well more, strange people always seem to walk in front of me, anyway! I overheard a familiar guitar riff over the speaker system. My heart leaped, because secretly, I’m in love with Peter Frampton and “Baby, I Love Your Way”. I paused briefly, my head cocked to the side for better reception into my right ear, my eyes glazed over in blissful anticipation of what was surely to come!
Until a female, jazzy, breathy voice started to warble over the speaker system. Now, as I was almost positive that Frampton had not undergone any reconstructive surgery of any sort, and even if he had his voice would not have changed much, I was appalled. Now I have nothing against women singing rock n roll, I mean Grace Slick, c’mon. But you don’t get to take Frampton and make it POP! If you cover a song, you make it better, not ELEVATOR TRASH.
Seriously, to all the musical artists of the world today, don’t cover a classic unless you’re sure you can make it better or make it so different it’s an entirely different song.
That goes to you, Madonna (American Pie), Hilary Duff (My Generation), Jay-Z (Kashmir), and of course overly breathy jazz singer (Baby, I Love Your Way).
And seriously Jay-Z. No body fucks with Led Zeppelin on my watch. NO BODY. So I now have a personal vendetta against you, even if you are the president of a record company.
And P.S. I know Jimmy Page is partly to blame, but I prefer to blame the mind altering affects of the 60s for his lapse in judgement, because you just don’t blame Guitar Gods. It’s morally wrong.